Eben Goodale, Ping Ding, Xiaohu Liu, Ari Martínez, Xingfeng Si, Mitch Walters, Scott K. Robinson. 2015: The structure of mixed-species bird flocks, and their response to anthropogenic disturbance, with special reference to East Asia. Avian Research, 6(1): 14. DOI: 10.1186/s40657-015-0023-0
Citation: Eben Goodale, Ping Ding, Xiaohu Liu, Ari Martínez, Xingfeng Si, Mitch Walters, Scott K. Robinson. 2015: The structure of mixed-species bird flocks, and their response to anthropogenic disturbance, with special reference to East Asia. Avian Research, 6(1): 14. DOI: 10.1186/s40657-015-0023-0

The structure of mixed-species bird flocks, and their response to anthropogenic disturbance, with special reference to East Asia

More Information
  • Corresponding author:

    ScottK.Robinson, srobinson@flmnh.ufl.edu

  • Received Date: 14 Aug 2014
  • Accepted Date: 01 Jun 2015
  • Available Online: 24 Apr 2022
  • Publish Date: 31 Jul 2015
  • Mixed-species flocks of birds are distributed world-wide and can be especially dominant in temperate forests during the non-breeding season and in tropical rainforests year-round. We review from a community ecology perspective what is known about the structure and organization of flocks, emphasizing that flocking species tend to be those particularly vulnerable to predation, and flocks tend to be led by species that are able to act as sources of information about predators for other species. Studies on how flocks respond to fragmentation and land-use intensification continue to accumulate, but the question of whether the flock phenomenon makes species more vulnerable to anthropogenic change remains unclear. We review the literature on flocks in East Asia and demonstrate there is a good foundation of knowledge on which to build. We then outline potentially fruitful future directions, focusing on studies that can investigate how dependent species are on each other in flocks, and how such interdependencies might affect avian habitat selection in the different types of human-modified environments of this region.

  • The Crested Ibis (Nipponia nippon, Plates Ⅰ and ) (Ciconiiformes: Threskiornithidae) is a medium-sized wading bird, ranging in length from 57.5 to 84.0 cm, with a longish neck and legs, a red featherless face with a crested white head. Its most distinctive morphological character is the long, slender and decurved bill, perfectly adapted for probing in water and mud, or even in cracks on dry ground. The non-breeding adult is white, with orange cinnamon tones in the tail and flight-feathers. The long bill is black with a red tip. Its red legs do not extend beyond the tail in flight (Hoyo et al., 1992).

      Plate Ⅰ.  Crested Ibis (Nipponia nippon). (a) Crested Ibis in flight; (b) Young Crested Ibis (photos by Zhinong Xi).
      Plate Ⅱ.  Crested Ibis (Nipponia nippon). (a) Non-breeding Crested Ibis (photo by Changqing Ding); (b) Feeding the chicks (photo by Jingquan Jiao); (c) Adult and fledglings (photo by Changqing Ding).

    The Crested Ibis is categorized as Endangered (EN) in the IUCN Red List (BirdLife International, 2001) and is listed in Appendix Ⅰ of CITES. It is also ranked as a first class national key protected animal in China (Zheng and Wang, 1998; Ding, 2004).

    The Crested Ibis was widespread and locally common in North-East Asia until the late nineteenth century, when it was breeding in far eastern Russia, Japan and mainland China and was a presumed non-breeding visitor to the Korea Peninsula and Taiwan Island (Fig. 1). The population of the Crested Ibis rapidly declined in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, related to deforestation of pine woodlands as nesting habitat, human persuit, especially over-hunting, drying out of wetland and the abuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides in paddy fields during the 1950's. This species was even evaluated as extinct in the wild (EW) when the last five wild birds in Japan were caught into captivity in 1981.

    Figure  1.  Distribution of Crested Ibis (Imitated from BirdLife International, 2001)

    In China, the last specimen was collected in Gansu Province in 1964, after which there were no records for a long time (Ding, 2004). In May 1981, after three years of a nation-wide survey, a tiny wild population of seven birds (two pairs and three fledglings) was re-discovered in Yangxian, Shaanxi Province in central China and renewed hope for this species (Liu, 1981).

    After the rediscovery of the wild population, the Chinese government and authorities have made great efforts for the conservation of the Crested Ibis and its habitats. The Shaanxi Crested Ibis Nature Reserve was established in 1990 and this magnificent bird has since been the focus of intensive conservation efforts. The seven original birds are the source of all present Crested Ibis populations, both in the wild and in captivity. Now there is only one wild population remaining in the world, located in Yangxian and nearby counties in Shaanxi Province and has been gradually recovering to more than 600 birds in 2007 (Fig. 2) (Zhang and Ding, 2008). One reintroduced population of about 20 birds has been established in Ningshan County, Shaanxi Province since 2007.

    Figure  2.  Population size of the wild Crested Ibis from 1981 to 2007

    Six fledglings were taken from the wild to initiate a captive population in Beijing Zoo before 1986, where the first successful breeding was achieved in 1989 (Li, 1991). Another captive rearing and breeding program began at the Shaanxi Crested Ibis Breeding Centre in 1990 with the rescue of sick or injured chicks and the collection of some of the eggs deserted by parental birds in the wild (Xi et al., 2002). There are now five captive populations with a total of about 600 birds in the Beijing Zoo, Yangxian and Zhouzhi counties of Shaanxi Province, the Dongzhai Nature Reserve of Henan Province and in Deqing County of Zhejiang Province.

    The annual activity of the Crested Ibis can be divided into a breeding season (February to June), a wandering season (July to October) and a wintering season (November to January) (Wang and Shi, 2000). The breeding areas are located in middle and lower mountains with wintering paddy fields, nesting on tall trees, close to villages. The position of the nest sites is closely related to the availability of feeding grounds and many nests are built close to human settlements, often less than 100 m and sometimes the nest tree is only a few meters from a human settlement. The trunks of nest trees (and adjacent trees) are covered with plastic cloth or razor blades to prevent snakes from climbing up and nets are placed under the nests to catch any chicks that fall out (Ding and Li, 2005).

    The mating system is monogamous. Male and female birds both contribute to nesting, hatching and feeding chicks. Pairs will use the same nesting territory if not disturbed. In the past they were observed to re-use old nests but most pairs now build new nests every year (Shi et al., 2001).

    The wild population no longer migrates, only making short flights to feed in paddy fields below 700 m during the winter and moving to higher elevations (up to 1200 m) to nest in the spring. During the wandering season, the birds move about 25 km (15−45 km) from their breeding areas to planes along the Hanjiang River. They move back to their breeding areas during the wintering season. During the non-breeding season, the ibises gather in flocks for feeding and roosting.

    Breeding starts in late February to early March, with laying from mid March to early April. Nests are flimsy stick platforms, lined with small twigs, leaves and hay, built on branches of trees (Pinus massoniana, Quercus variabilis, chestnut or poplar), at heights of 4−22 m. Usually there are 3−4 eggs per nest, the incubation period is about 28 days; chicks have gray down, white below and become fledglings after 40−45 days. The young birds are sexually mature in 2−3 years. Captive birds in Japan have lived to become 37 years old.

    The size of the home range averages 100.8 ± 49.8 ha (according to MCP method) and 175.6 ± 91.3 ha (according to 90% Kernel method); the breeding home range of different pairs overlaps about 24.5 ± 27.3% and some pairs can overlap up to 46.8−64.3% (Liu et al., 2003).

    The success of fledglings from the wild population was only 11% in the early 1980s, but with effective conservation measures taken since then, it increased to 53% in the late 1990s (Shi and Cao, 2001). Because a high proportion of the wild population consists of young birds that have not yet started to breed (Lu et al., 2000), it is predicted that the wild population of the Crested Ibis will continue to increase and that they will expand their breeding range. The distribution area has been increased from less than 100 km2 to more than 3000 km2 at present. The discovery of a nesting pair in Xixiang County of Shannxi Province in 1999 provides evidence for such an expansion (Ding et al., 1999). Figure 3 shows the dispersal of breeding sites from 20 nests in 1999 to 102 nests in 2007 (Zhang and Ding, 2008).

    Figure  3.  Nest site distribution of Crested Ibis showing the dispersal of the wild population (a: 1999, b: 2007).

    Birds forage during the daytime in small flocks, probe into mud or shallow water with their bill, or pick up prey from the ground. The diet consists of freshwater fish (loaches and eels), amphibians (frogs, newts and salamanders), crustaceans, freshwater mollusks and insects, especially grasshoppers, crickets and adults and larvae of aquatic beetles.

    In winter, the main feeding habitats are paddy fields, riverbanks and reservoirs, mainly close to human settlements. Birds seem able to tolerate human activities in these areas (Ma et al., 2001). The areas where they currently breed are at 470–1300 m elevation (Ma et al., 2001), but elders in Yangxian reported that, prior to the 1940s, they were usually found at lower elevations in areas with slow-flowing rivers. In recent years, they have tended to move into new nesting sites at lower elevations in this area (Zhai et al., 2001), presumably indicating that this relict population had become confined to suboptimal upland areas but is now expanding back into more typical lowland habitats.

    The use of fertilizer and pesticides usually causes pollution in feeding areas and threatens food diversity and richness of the Crested Ibis, especially in the chick hatching period. Research has indicated that food shortage is a major factor affecting the chick survival rate (Ding, 2004). Food supplementation in paddy fields is an effective measure during the breeding season.

    Since there is only one wild population in the world, found in a very limited area, the Crested Ibis cannot avoid being threatened. If wildlife diseases (such as New Castle disease and bird flu), climate disasters (such as heavy snow and extreme drought during breeding season) and outbreaks of pollution in feeding areas, the wild population of the Crested Ibis will be faced with a serious threat to its survival. It is urgently required to conduct a reintroduction program to establish a second and third wild population in other areas (Ding and Li, 2005).

    At present, with the development of captive breeding populations, there are enough captive birds reserved for release into the wild. In 2004, the State Forestry Administration (SFA) organized a survey for reintroduction sites in China (Ding and Li, 2005). GIS techniques were used to detect potential suitable breeding sites for the Crested Ibis (Liu et al., 2006). Since then, four captive populations have been established for wild training in Huayang, Ningshan, Dongzhai and Deqing. Where could potential reintroduction places be found?

    In October 2004, a small captive population was transferred to Huayang, a higher elevation area in Yangxian, for wild training. Up to 2006, 23 birds were released. Now the released birds have joined the local wild population and eight of them bred successfully in seven nests in 2010.

    In May 2007, 26 birds were released in Ningshan County, Shaanxi Province. It was the first reintroduction attempt of the Crested Ibis. With 16 more birds released later, there are more than 20 birds surviving in Ningshan and five pairs of them bred with six fledglings surviving in 2009 (XY Chang, unpublished data).

  • Alatalo RV (1981) Interspecific competition in tits Parus spp. and the Goldcrest Regulus regulus: foraging shifts in multispecific flocks. Oikos 37:335–44
    Alatalo RV, Gustafsson L, Linden M, Lundberg A (1985) Interspecific competition and niche shifts in tits and the goldcrest: an experiment. J Anim Ecol 54:977–84
    Alatalo RV, Eriksson DAG, Gustafsson L, Larsson K (1987) Exploitation competition influences the use of foraging sites by tits: experimental evidence. Ecology 68:284–90
    Aplin LM, Farine DR, Morand-Ferron J, Sheldon BC (2012) Social networks predict patch discovery in a wild population of songbirds. Proc R Soc Lond B 279:4199–205
    Buskirk WH (1976) Social systems in a tropical forest avifauna. Am Nat 110:293–310
    Buskirk WH, Powell GVN, Wittenberger JF, Buskirk RE, Powell TU (1972) Interspecific bird flocks in tropical highland Panama. Auk 89:612–24
    Caraco T, Martindale S, Pulliam HR (1980) Avian flocking in the presence of a predator. Nature 285:400–1
    Chen C-C, Hsieh H (2002) Composition and foraging behaviour of mixed-species flocks led by the grey-cheeked fulvetta in fushan experimental forest, Taiwan. Ibis 144:317–30
    Cimprich DA, Grubb TC Jr (1994) Consequences for Carolina chickadees of foraging with Tufted Titmice in winter. Ecology 75:1615–25
    Collar N, Robson C, Christie DA (2013) Grey-cheeked Fulvetta (Alcippe morrisonia). In: del Hoyo J, Elliott A, Sargatal J, Christie DA, de Juana E (eds) Handbook of the Birds of the World Alive. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona
    Colorado GJ (2013) Why animals come together, with the special case of mixed-species bird flocks. Rev Esc Ingeniería de Antioquia 10:49–66
    Colorado GJ, Rodewald AD (2015) Assembly patterns of mixed‐species avian flocks in the Andes. J Anim Ecol 84:386–95
    Colorado GJ, Rodewald AD (in press) Response of mixed-species flocks to habitat alteration and deforestation in the Andes. Biol Conserv. doi:
    Contreras TA, Sieving KE (2011) Leadership of winter mixed-species flocks by Tufted Titmice (Baeolophus bicolor): are titmice passive nuclear species? Int J Zool 2011:670548
    Cordeiro NJ, Borghesio L, Joho M, Monoski T, Mkongewa V (2014) Forest fragmentation in an African biodiversity hotspot impacts mixed species foraging bird flocks. Biol Conserv. doi:
    Darrah AJ, Smith KG (2013) Comparison of foraging behaviors and movement patterns of the Wedge-billed Woodcreeper (Glyphorynchus spirurus) traveling alone and in mixed-species flocks in Amazonian Ecuador. Auk 130:629–36
    Develey PF, Stouffer PC (2001) Effects of roads on movements by understorey birds in mixed-species flocks in central Amazonian Brazil. Conserv Biol 15:1416–22
    Diamond JM (1981) Mixed-species foraging groups. Nature 292:408–9
    Dolby AS, Grubb TC Jr (1998) Benefits to satellite members in mixed-species foraging groups: an experimental analysis. Anim Behav 56:501–9
    Dolby AS, Grubb TC Jr (1999) Functional roles in mixed-species foraging flocks: a field manipulation. Auk 116:557–9
    Dolby AS, Grubb TC Jr (2000) Social context affects risk taking by a satellite species in a mixed-species foraging group. Behav Ecol 11:110–4
    Eguchi K, Yamagishi S, Randrianasolo V (1993) The composition and foraging behaviour of mixed-species flocks of forest-living birds in Madagascar. Ibis 135:91–6
    Farine DR, Milburn PJ (2013) Social organisation of thornbill-dominated mixed-species flocks using social network analysis. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 67:321–30
    Fernández-Juricic E (2000) Forest fragmentation affects winter flock formation of an insectivorous guild. Ardea 88:235–41
    Fernández-Juricic E (2002) Nested patterns of species distribution and winter flock occurrence of insectivorous birds in a fragmented landscape. Ecoscience 9:450–8
    Fregin S, Haase M, Olsson U, Alström P (2012) New insights into family relationships within the avian superfamily Sylvioidea (Passeriformes) based on seven molecular markers. BMC Evol Biol 12:157
    Galef BG, Giraldeau L-A (2001) Social influences on foraging in vertebrates: causal mechanisms and adaptive functions. Anim Behav 61:3–15
    Gao W (1987) Study of flocks of terrestrial birds on Mt. Changbai and their annual activities. J Northeast Normal Univ 1987:63–72
    Gao W (1991) The relationship of birds in mixed flocks in winter in a planted larch forest. Chinese J Zool 26:9–12
    Gao W, Feng H-L, Xiang G-Q, Yang Z-J, Cheng H (1993) On bird flocking in secondary forest of mountainous district in winter. Acta Zool Sinica 39:385–91
    Gill F, Donsker D (2014) International Ornithologists' Union world bird list (v. 3.3).
    Gillies CS, St Clair CC (2010) Functional responses in habitat selection by tropical birds moving through fragmented forest. J Appl Ecol 47:182–90
    Gómez JP, Bravo GA, Brumfield RT, Tello JG, Cadena CD (2010) A phylogenetic approach to disentangling the role of competition and habitat filtering in community assembly of Neotropical forest birds. J Anim Ecol 79:1181–92
    Goodale E, Beauchamp G (2010) The relationship between leadership and gregariousness in mixed-species bird flocks. J Avian Biol 41:99–103
    Goodale E, Kotagama SW (2005a) Alarm calling in Sri Lankan mixed-species bird flocks. Auk 122:108–20
    Goodale E, Kotagama SW (2005b) Testing the roles of species in mixed-species bird flocks of a Sri Lankan rainforest. J Trop Ecol 21:669–76
    Goodale E, Nizam BZ, Robin VV, Sridhar H, Trivedi P, Kotagama SW, Padmalal UKGK, Perera R, Pramod P, Vijayan L (2009) Regional variation in the composition and structure of mixed-species bird flocks in the Western Ghats and Sri Lanka. Curr Sci India 97:648–63
    Goodale E, Beauchamp G, Magrath R, Nieh JC, Ruxton GD (2010) Interspecific information transfer influences animal community structure. Trends Ecol Evol 25:354–61
    Goodale E, Goodale UM, Mana R (2012) The role of toxic pitohuis in mixed-species flocks of lowland forest in Papua New Guinea. Emu 112:9–16
    Goodale E, Kotagama SW, Raman TRS, Sidhu S, Goodale UM, Parker S, Chen J (2014) The response of birds and mixed-species bird flocks to human-modified landscapes in Sri Lanka and southern India. Forest Ecol Manag 329:384–92
    Gradwohl J, Greenberg R (1980) The formation of antwren flocks on Barro Colorado Island, Panama. Auk 97:385–95
    Gram WK (1998) Winter participation by Neotropical migrant and resident birds in mixed-species flocks in northeastern Mexico. Condor 100:44–53
    Graves GR, Gotelli NJ (1993) Assembly of avian mixed-species flocks in Amazonia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 90:1388–91
    Greenberg R (2000) Birds of many feathers: the formation and structure of mixed-species flocks of forest birds. In: Boinski S, Garber PA (eds) On the move: how and why animals travel in groups. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 521–58
    Greig-Smith PW (1981) The role of alarm responses in the formation of mixed-species flocks of heathland birds. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 8:7–10
    Harrison NM, Whitehouse MJ (2011) Mixed-species flocks: an example of niche construction? Anim Behav 81:675–82
    Hino T (1998) Mutualistic and commensal organization of avian mixed-species foraging flocks in a forest of western Madagascar. J Avian Biol 29:17–24
    Hino T (2005) Resident males of small species dominate immigrants of large species in heterospecific, winter bird flocks. Ornithol Sci 4:89–94
    Holt RD (1997) Community modules. In: Gange AC, Brown VK (eds) Multitrophic interactions in terrestrial ecosystems. Blackwell Science, Oxford, pp 333–49
    Hsieh H, Chen C-C (2011) Does niche-overlap facilitate mixed-species flocking in birds? J Ornithol 152:955–63
    Hutto RL (1987) A description of mixed-species insectivorous bird flocks in western Mexico. Condor 89:282–92
    Hutto RL (1988) Foraging behaviour patterns suggest a possible cost associated with participation in mixed-species bird flocks. Oikos 51:79–83
    Jabłoński PG, Lee SD (2002) Foraging niche shifts in mixed-species flocks of tits in Korea. J Field Ornithol 73:246–52
    Jankowski JE, Robinson SK, Levey DJ (2010) Squeezed at the top: interspecific aggression may constrain elevational ranges in tropical birds. Ecology 91:1877–84
    Jankowski JE, Graham CH, Parra JL, Robinson SK, Seddon N, Touchton JM, Tobias JA (2012) The role of competition in structuring tropical bird communities. Ornitol Neotrop 23:115–24
    Jiang A (2007) The study of understory birds in Nonggang karst forest. MSc Thesis, Guangxi University, Nanning
    Jullien M, Clobert J (2000) The survival value of flocking in neotropical birds: reality or fiction? Ecology 81:3416–30
    Jullien M, Thiollay J-M (1998) Multi-species territoriality and dynamic of neotropical forest understorey bird flocks. J Anim Ecol 67:227–52
    Kawakami K, Higuchi H (2003) Interspecific interactions between the native and introduced White-eyes in the Bonin Islands. Ibis 145:583–92
    Kiers ET, Palmer TM, Ives AR, Bruno JF, Bronstein JL (2010) Mutualisms in a changing world: an evolutionary perspective. Ecol Lett 13:1459–74
    King DI, Rappole JH (2000) Winter flocking of insectivorous birds in montane pine-oak forests in middle America. Condor 102:664–72
    Knowlton JL, Graham CH (2011) Species interactions are disrupted by habitat degradation in the highly threatened Tumbesian region of Ecuador. Ecol Appl 21:2974–86
    Kotagama SW, Goodale E (2004) The composition and spatial organization of mixed-species flocks in a Sri Lankan rainforest. Forktail 20:63–70
    Krams I (2001) Seeing without being seen: a removal experiment with mixed flocks of willow and crested tits Parus montanus and cristatus. Ibis 143:476–81
    Krebs JR (1973) Social learning and the significance of mixed-species flocks of chickadees (Parus spp.). Can J Zool 51:1275–88
    Kubota H, Nakamura M (2000) Effects of supplemental food on intra-and inter-specific behaviour of the Varied Tit Parus varius. Ibis 142:312–9
    Latta SC, Wunderle JM (1996) The composition and foraging ecology of mixed-species flocks in pine forests of Hispaniola. Condor 98:595–607
    Lee SD, Jabłoński PG (1999) Species composition and use of coniferous and deciduous trees in mixed-species flocks wintering near Seoul (Korea). Act Ornithol 34:81–4
    Lee SD, Jabłoński PG (2006) Spatial segregation of foraging sites in winter mixed-species flocks of forest birds near Seoul, Korea. Pol J Ecol 54:481–90
    Lee TM, Soh MCK, Sodhi N, Koh LP, Lim SL-H (2005) Effects of habitat disturbance on mixed species bird flocks in a tropical sub-montane rainforest. Biol Conserv 122:193–204
    Ma Z, Cheng Y, Wang J, Fu X (2013) The rapid development of birdwatching in mainland China: a new force for bird study and conservation. Bird Conserv Int 23:259–69
    MacKinnon J, Phillipps K (2000) A field guide to the birds of China. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK
    Maldonado-Coelho M, Marini MA (2000) Effects of forest fragment size and successional stage on mixed-species bird flocks in southeastern Brazil. Condor 102:585–94
    Maldonado-Coelho M, Marini MA (2004) Mixed-species bird flocks from Brazilian Atlantic forest: the effects of forest fragmentation and seasonality on their size, richness and stability. Biol Conserv 116:19–26
    Martínez AE, Gomez JP (2013) Are mixed-species bird flocks stable through two decades? Am Nat 181:E53–9
    Maynard Smith J (1965) The evolution of alarm calls. Am Nat 99:59–63
    McClure HE (1967) The composition of mixed-species flocks in lowland and sub-montane forests of Malaya. Wilson Bull 79:131–54
    McDermott ME, Rodewald AD (2014) Conservation value of silvopastures to Neotropical migrants in Andean forest flocks. Biol Conserv 175:140–7
    Mokross K, Ryder TB, Côrtes MC, Wolfe JD, Stouffer PC (2014) Decay of interspecific avian flock networks along a disturbance gradient in Amazonia. Proc R Soc Lond B 281:20132599
    Mönkkönen M, Forsman JT, Helle P (1996) Mixed-species foraging aggregations and heterospecific attraction in boreal bird communities. Oikos 77:127–36
    Morse DH (1970) Ecological aspects of some mixed-species foraging flocks of birds. Ecol Monogr 40:119–68
    Morse DH (1977) Feeding behavior and predator avoidance in heterospecific groups. Bioscience 27:332–9
    Moynihan M (1962) The organization and probable evolution of some mixed-species flocks of Neotropical birds. Smithson Misc Coll 143:1–140
    Munn CA (1984) The behavioral ecology of mixed-species bird flocks in Amazonian Peru. Princeton University, New Jersey
    Munn CA (1985) Permanent canopy and understorey flocks in Amazonia: species composition and population density. Ornithol Monogr 36:683–712
    Munn CA, Terborgh JW (1979) Multi-species territoriality in Neotropical foraging flocks. Condor 81:338–47
    Nakamura M, Shindo N (2001) Effects of snow cover on the social and foraging behavior of the great tit Parus major. Ecol Res 16:301–8
    Ogasawara K (1965) The analysis of the mixed flock of the family Paridae in the botanical garden of the Tôhuku University, Sendai. I: Seasonal change of the flock formation. Scientific Report of the Tôhuku University. Series Ⅳ (Biology) 31: 167–80
    Ogasawara K (1970) Analysis of mixed-species flocks of tits in the botanical garden of Tôhoku University Sendai Ⅱ Foragin g layers by species and their interrelations within the mixed flock. Miscellaneous Reports of the Yamashima Institute of Ornithology 6: 170–8
    Ogasawara K (1975) Analysis of mixed-species flocks of tits in the botanical garden of Tôhoku University, Sendai. Ⅳ. Foraging habits and supplanting attacks among species forming mixed flocks. Miscellaneous Reports of the Yamashima Institute of Ornithology 12: 637–51
    Péron G, Crochet P-A (2009) Edge effect and structure of mixed-species bird flocks in an Afrotropical lowland forest. J Ornithol 150:585–99
    Pierpont N (1986) Interspecific aggression and the ecology of woodcreepers (Aves: Dendrocolaptidae). Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey, PhD Thesis
    Pomara LY, Cooper RJ, Petit LJ (2003) Mixed-species flocking and foraging behavior of four neotropical warblers in Panamanian shade coffee fields and forests. Auk 120:1000–12
    Pomara LY, Cooper RJ, Petit LJ (2007) Modeling the flocking propensity of passerine birds in two Neotropical habitats. Oecologia 153:121–33
    Powell GVN (1985) Sociobiology and adaptive significance of interspecific foraging flocks in the Neotropics. Ornithol Monogr 36:713–32
    Satischandra SHK, Kudavidanage EP, Kotagama SW, Goodale E (2007) The benefits of joining mixed-species flocks for a sentinel nuclear species, the Greater Racket-tailed Drongo Dicrurus paradiseus. Forktail 23:145–8
    Seki S-I, Sato T (2002) The effect of a typhoon on the flocking and forgaging behavior of tits. Ornithol Sci 1:53–61
    Si X-F, Ding P (2011) History, status of monitoring landbirds in Europe and America and countermeasures of China. Biodiv Sci 19:303–10
    Sidhu S, Raman TRS, Goodale E (2010) Effects of plantations and home-gardens on tropical forest bird communities and mixed-species bird flocks in the southern Western Ghats. J Bombay Nat Hist Soc 107:91–108
    Sieving KE, Contreras TA, Maute KL (2004) Heterospecific facilitation of forest boundary crossing by mobbing understory birds in north-central Florida. Auk 121:738–51
    Smith SM (1991) The Black-capped Chickadee: behavioral ecology and natural history. Comstock Books, Ithaca
    Song Y-J (1981) Studies on the breeding behaviour and feeding habits of Long-tailed tit. Zool Res 2:235–42
    Sridhar H, Sankar K (2008) Effects of habitat degradation on mixed-species bird flocks in Indian rain forests. J Trop Ecol 24:135–47
    Sridhar H, Shanker K (2014) Using intra-flock association patterns to understand why birds participate in mixed-species foraging flocks in terrestrial habitats. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 68:185–96
    Sridhar H, Beauchamp G, Shanker K (2009) Why do birds participate in mixed-species foraging flocks? A large-scale synthesis. Anim Behav 78:337–47
    Sridhar H, Srinivasan U, Askins RA, Canales-Delgadillo JC, Chen C-C, Ewert DN, Gale GA, Goodale E, Gram WK, Hart PJ, Hobson KA, Hutto RL, Kotagama SW, Knowlton JL, Lee TM, Munn CA, Nimnuan S, Nizam BZ, Péron G, Robin VV, Rodewald AD, Rodewald PG, Thomson RL, Trivedi P, Van Wilgenburg SL, Shanker K (2012) Positive relationships between association strength and phenotypic similarity characterize the assembly of mixed-species bird flocks worldwide. Am Nat 180:777–90
    Sridhar H, Jordán F, Shanker K (2013) Species importance in a heterospecific foraging association network. Oikos 122:1325–34
    Srinivasan U, Quader S (2012) To eat and not be eaten: modelling resources and safety in multi-species animal groups. PLoS One 7, e42071
    Srinivasan U, Raza RH, Quader S (2010) The nuclear question: rethinking species importance in multi-species animal groups. J Anim Ecol 79:948–54
    Stouffer PC, Bierregaard RO Jr (1995) Use of Amazonian forest fragments by understory insectivorous birds. Ecology 76:2429–45
    Sullivan KA (1984) Information exploitation by downy woodpeckers in mixed-species flocks. Behaviour 91:294–311
    Suzuki TN (2012) Long-distance caling by the Willow Tit, Poecile montanus, facilitates formation of mixed-species foraging flocks. Ethology 118:10–6
    Tellería JL, Virgós E, Carbonell R, Pérez-Tris J, Santos T (2001) Behavioural responses to changing landscapes: flock structure and anti-predator strategies of tits wintering in fragmented forests. Oikos 95:253–64
    Terborgh J (1971) Distribution on environmental gradients: theory and preliminary investigation of distributional patterns in the avifauna of the Cordillera Vilcabamba, Peru. Ecology 52:23–40
    Terborgh J (1990) Mixed flocks and polyspecific associations: costs and benefits of mixed groups to birds and monkeys. Am J Primatol 21:87–100
    Terborgh J, Lopez L, Nuñez P, Rao M, Shahabuddin G, Orihuela G, Riveros M, Ascanio R, Adler GH, Lambert TD, Balbas L (2001) Ecological meltdown in predator-free forest fragments. Science 294:1923–6
    Thiollay J-M (1992) Influence of selective logging on bird species diversity in a Guianan rain forest. Conserv Biol 6:47–60
    Thiollay J-M (1999a) Frequency of mixed-species flocking in tropical forest birds and correlates of predation risk: an intertropical comparison. J Avian Biol 30:282–94
    Thiollay J-M (1999b) Responses of an avian community to rain forest degradation. Biodiv Conserv 8:513–34
    Thiollay J-M (2003) Comparative foraging behavior between solitary and flocking insectivores in a Neotropical forest: does vulnerability matter? Ornitol Neotrop 14:47–65
    Thiollay J-M, Jullien M (1998) Flocking behaviour of foraging birds in a neotropical rain forest and the antipredator defence hypothesis. Ibis 140:382–94
    Tubelis DP, Cowling A, Donnelley C (2006) Role of mixed-species flocks in the use of adjacent savannas by forest birds in the central Cerrado, Brazil. Austral Ecol 31:38–45
    Tylianakis JM, Laliberté E, Nielsen A, Bascompte J (2009) Conservation of species interaction networks. Biol Conserv 143:2270–9
    Valburg LK (1992) Flocking and frugivory: the effect of social groupings on resource use in the Common Bush-Tanager. Condor 94:358–63
    Valiente-Banuet A, Aizen MA, Alcántara JM, Arroyo J, Cocucci A, Galetti M, García MB, García D, Gómez JM, Jordano P (2015) Beyond species loss: the extinction of ecological interactions in a changing world. Funct Ecol 29:299–307
    Van Houtan KS, Pimm SL, Bierregaard RO Jr, Lovejoy TE, Stouffer PC (2006) Local extinctions in flocking birds in Amazonian forest fragments. Evol Ecol Res 8:129–48
    Waite TA, Grubb TC Jr (1988) Copying of foraging locations in mixed-species flocks of temperate-deciduous woodland birds: an experimental study. Condor 90:132–40
    Wang Z (1983) Some information on birds of the bamboo jungle in the Xujiaba evergreen broadleaf forest. Act Ecol Sinica 3:393–8
    Wang Y, Chen S, Ping D (2011) Testing mutliple assembly rule models in avian communities on islands of an inundated lake, Zhejiang Province, China. J Biogeogr 38:1330–44
    Webb CO, Ackerly DD, McPeek MA, Donoghue MJ (2002) Phylogenies and community ecology. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 33:475–505
    Winterbottom JM (1943) On woodland bird parties in Northern Rhodesia. Ibis 85:437–42
    Zhang Q, Han RC, Zhang M, Huang Z, Zou F (2013) Linking vegetation structure and bird organization: response of mixed-species bird flocks to forest succession in subtropical China. Biodiv Conserv 22:1965–89
    Zhao Z (2001) The birds of China. Jilin Science and Technology Press, Changchun, Jilin
    Zhuge Y (1990) Fauna of Zhejiang: Aves. Zhejiang Science and Technology Publishing House, Hangzhou
    Zou F, Chen G, Yang Q, Fellowes J (2011) Composition of mixed-species flocks and shifts in foraging location of flocking species on Hainan Island, China. Ibis 153:269–78
  • Related Articles

Catalog

    Figures(2)  /  Tables(1)

    Article Metrics

    Article views (486) PDF downloads (26) Cited by()

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return